PHL 1623: Ethics

Matthew M. Daude

Section 4491

Summer, 1999

The ACC catalogue describes this course as "A study of the principles of morality with a critical examination of various ethical theories and their application to contemporary moral issues." Our goal in this course will be to learn and to practice cogent reasoning about moral problems. Consequently, we will discuss the ethical views of certain philosophers in order to learn how they reasoned about the problems with which they were concerned, and we will practice such reasoning by applying their theories to moral problems that concern us today. Our theme for this semester is technology and public life. We will explore the ways in which philosophical theories about morality might shed light on problematic cases in this general topic area.

We will pursue three goals in this course:

    1. To learn and to practice cogent reasoning about moral problems
    2. To become acquainted with several major ethical theories
    3. To apply these theories to particular cases concerning technology and public life

Preliminary Issues

There are no course prerequisites for Ethics. A passing score or the equivalent on the reading portion of the TASP is required, and I highly recommend a passing score or the equivalent on the writing portion. The major form of evaluation will be written work, and the main instructional methods will include lecture, student presentations, and discussion.

Our objectives for the semester reflect the goals listed above: demonstration of improved critical thinking skills, familiarity with the basic problems and concepts of ethical theory, and a working knowledge of the theories we will study.

I will have course materials posted on the Ethics main page, and I strongly encourage you to get an email account, if you do not already have one. (If you would like some help getting an email account, let me know. See the email guidelines below for more details.)

Office Hours

Mondays 1:30-3:30 PM

RVS 2283

Tuesdays 2:00-4:00 PM RGC 017
Wednesdays 3:00-4:00 PM RGC 017
  (Other times by appointment)  
Office  

RVS 2283

Voicemail  

223-6132

Texts and Reading Assignments

PHL1623 Packet of Readings

The readings of classical authors will be available on-line; check the Ethics main page for details. I will ask you to purchase a packet of readings by modern authors as well; we will discuss this packet in class.

There will be a number of handouts, most of which will be available on-line. If you find that you must miss class, please get the handouts prior to the next class. Look for reading assignments on-line as well. I expect everyone to come to class having read and thought about the assignment. Reading philosophy takes tenacity; expect to spend at least a couple of hours outside of class for every hour we spend in class. Be sure to get in touch with me if you are having problems with the course content.

Work and Grading Policy

The first component of the course will deal with the most influential ethical theories (natural law, utilitarianism, contractarianism, virtue ethics, and Kantianism). The second component of the course will be an exploration of various moral problems that fall under the general theme of "technology and public life." We will discuss the topic area in more detail as the semester proceeds. You will have the opportunity to pursue individual interests within this general heading and share these interests with the class in your presentation.

Your grade for this course will be based on written and collaborative work demonstrating the pursuit of the goals of the course. There are four components:

Theory exams

50%

Final Exam

15%

Term Paper

20%

Class participation

15%

We will talk about the course components in much more detail in class, but the comments under Coursework Guidelines will give you the main idea. Due dates for written work will be arranged in class; please check here regularly for announcements and deadlines. Please note that I will not accept work after the stated due date, except by prior agreement. All written work done outside of class must be typed (using a standard font—no italics!) and double-spaced. Please see the General Course Policies for further information.

Coursework Guidelines

You may submit written work done outside of class by email; please follow the email guidelines below. I strongly encourage you to get an email account and use the web-based materials available for this class.

The Theory Exams

There will be an exam on each of the theories we study. The exam will consist of three essay questions which involve application of the theory to a scenario. The evaluation will be based on your understanding of the theory, application to the cases given, and your defense (reasons, justification, explanation, etc.).

For fans of Bloom's taxonomy, the exams are intended to be at the level of application.

Final Exam

The final exam is final in the sense that it comes at the end of the course: you will be expected to reason cogently about moral issues and put your reasoning on paper, rather than simply to reproduce "information" covered through the semester. Consequently, I will give you several scenarios and ask you to find an appropriate "resolution," using some theoretical framework. These scenarios will be drawn from class discussion and presentations. You will be practicing this sort of reasoning throughout the semester. The final will also be a take-home essay test.

Term Paper/Presentation

The paper will be a five-page exploration of a moral issue relating to the class discussion. You should choose a topic question that falls under the course theme ("technology and public life"). Your paper should be an exploration of a particular moral problem and an application of a particular ethical theory. For example, you might explore the debate over guidelines for cloning research, and show how the application of a Natural Law theory of morality resolves some of the difficulties. Or, you might consider the creation of public policy regarding the use of fetal tissue in new treatments for degenerative brain disease, as guided by a Utilitarian theory.

Your paper should include the following elements:

  1. The relevant facts, plus a discussion of what it is about the facts that gives rise to a moral conflict
  2. The moral conflict (i.e., an explanation of "what the problem is")
  3. A resolution of the conflict by the application of one (or more) of the ethical theories we are studying

Concerning mechanics, I am not stipulating a particular format for this paper; any standard format for term papers is acceptable (MLA, for instance). However, please note that I will not accept an unformatted paper. I do expect you to use "outside" sources and to provide a bibliography.

We will discuss term papers in more detail as the semester unfolds. Please do not hesitate to contact me about your interests (email is good: mdaude@austincc.edu). I am requiring that you hand in a topic question and a rough draft. See the Ethics main page for due dates.

You should make use of the research for your paper in your class presentation. In your presentation you should explain points 1-3 above as they relate to your topic. Ideally, I would like you to hand out copies of a draft of your paper, along with a selection of supporting materials, so that we may have a general discussion of the moral problem. Minimally, you should give the class copies of the outline of your paper plus material that illustrates the moral quandary you have chosen. Please note that you must hand out materials at least one class period prior to your presentation date. Plan ahead!

As noted above, I will draw the final exam questions from presentations and ensuing class discussions.

Class Participation

Your class participation grade will be based on the preparation of your presentation as well as participation in class discussion. Be sure to have your handouts ready for the class at least one class period prior to your presentation date.

Readings

Please note that reading assignments are, in fact, coursework as well. In our class discussion, I will assume that you have done your readings (and thought about what you have read). I will announce reading assignments in class, and they will be posted on the reading assignment page.

Email

If you do not have access to email, contact me. There are many free services in cyberland (Hotmail, for instance) that you can access in one of ACC's computer labs. All you need to do is sign up. You can go to almost any open lab and get help from the techs (they are great!). You may submit any written work by email, but please follow these guidelines:

1. Use a standard subject heading on all email

    sect Last, First: Assignment

Once you set this up it's not hard to remember. "Sect" means the section number of the course in which you are enrolled, "Last, First" is your name, and "Assignment" means what you are sending. "Assignment" should be whatever we have given as the heading; for instance, the second exam would be

    4491 Daude, Matthew: Exam 2

An outline or draft of your term paper would like

    4491 Daude, Matthew: Term paper draft

If you just have a question or want to talk about something, use some short descriptive phrase:

    4491 Daude, Matthew: Question about the principle of utility

Remember to use your own name! (Yes, people have used my name . . . .) I know this is a pain, but it helps a great deal with organization on my end. Thanks in advance!

2. Send all work in the body of the email.

Don't send your work as an attachment! If you write assignments using a text editor, use the "cut-and-paste" functions to insert the text into the body of your email. Be sure to identify yourself and the assignment in the email!

3. Save your work!

The internet is fairly reliable, and so is my system, but problems do occasionally arise. Keep backups of all your work just in case!

Course Calendar

Check the Ethics main page  frequently for due dates and other announcements.

 


This page was last updated on 03/01/09 by mmd.